Hi Everyone,
This is my first time on the forum, and I only recently received a diagnosis of breast cancer (one breast, two lumps). Most of my family and friends have been lovely and hugely supportive. But I've had one difficult conversation from a member of my family (a sister who's often makes crass and insensitive comments about people - I keep her at arm's length for that reason). Having heard through another sister that I had cancer, she phoned, and her opener was "How did you get cancer?" in an accusatory, judgmental, sort of tone. Basically implying it was my fault. I was tempted to say oh I ordered it online from Amazon. But then she went on to say another unhelpful thing.... "You're the only one who's got it in the family". and went on to pointlessly speculate on the reasons why I had it. It's a hobby of hers, speculating. Unfortunately she's not alone in making an unhelpful and insensitive comments. Someone, whom I'm in email communication said today "there's a link between alcohol and cancer, I'll let you think on that". I was stunned, why on earth would someone say that? Why would even they think that ok? I have no idea why I have breast cancer, bad luck, age, genes, who knows, but booze is unlikely to be the culprit. And why even give that question headroom? Does anyone have ideas on how I can handle the stupid things that other people say?
Oh dear. I got some stupid comments. I ended up just ignoring those people because you can’t really give them an answer that they will appreciate. I had HPV oropharyngeal cancer and I got comments suggesting I’d been promiscuous. It’s lack of education. Ignore them. There’s no reasoning with some people.
Dani
Base of tongue cancer. T2N0M0 6 weeks Radiotherapy finished January 2019
I wrote a blog about my cancer. just click on the link below
That’s true but shocking nonetheless. Stupid comments are lack of education and poor emotional intelligence. I’m not terribly good at ignoring it. Everyone else has been supportive, thankfully.
Thanks for getting back to me,
All the best,
Adele
Hallo
thanks for posting this. People are stupid and thoughtless.
A long-standing friend said ooh how did you get cancer then, and other crass questions.
I was astounded and told her that I don’t know or care how I got cancer, I want to move forward and it’s a bit useless to speculate as I can’t change it.
This approach isn’t for everyone, it works for me. I don’t have time to waste, and I’ve found that I’ve had to be assertive as my partner has cancer too.
.
Wow! Those comments really take the biscuit. And they will hurt for much longer afterwards. There's been some good posts on this subject, I can't remember which one is the long good one, but one of these probably ->
RE: Starting to avoid people because of the silly things they say!!
Things people say/ask *after* you’ve had cancer
I think the middle one, members share their best answers.
You deserve a treat after such abuse.
One thing to give some thought to, and it isn't easy, those that react in the way you write about might be doing so because of their own fear. Even a sister, meaning another human you know better than many others, may have a fear of cancer that you knew nothing about and it could be that even though she seems to have a history of being not too cool with her words, this time it could be she is scared and she only knows one way to express that --- as she did, being kind of odd and nasty. Now I am no specialist about how folks think, but I used to be on active duty in the military many years ago and I noticed that some folks act really strange when they are scared. That could be the case here. But then you have the awful situation that you can't actually ask her if that is what's happening because she might be even worse in reacting to that, even if it turns out to be true. In fact, you may never know if that is the problem; that she is scared.
But it might be worth some thought. And maybe be a tad helpful.
Sorry for the delay in replying. Just catching up with myself after surgery. I agree, lack of education and knowledge at the heart of it. Nonetheless, the insensitivity of some people is staggering. All you can do is ignore them, although I've tried to also give my sister the facts as I understand them.
I find it shocking that some people react in this way. Particularly as you and your husband have a lot to deal with. No time to waste - too true I hope the situation has got better for you both.
Thanks, I checked the links out. A lot of it rings true, and very interesting that we quite a number of us receive odd, insensitive comments. I didn't think I'd have deal with that. Thankfully, everyone else close has been great and very supportive.
I've given it some thought. Fear, quite possibly, though my sister R decided (without evidence) that my breast cancer couldn't be genetic. Although I'm sure at the back of her mind she must wonder if she's going to be unlucky as well, particularly as there's been a lot of deaths in our family due to cancer (both parents, an aunt, grandparent). On another occasion she phoned and said something hurtful, I tried to be tactful back, but was pretty annoyed and shared it with my sister F, and she was shocked, and thought that R had become increasingly blunt and negative towards everyone, and had her own examples. I felt better about the situation knowing it wasn't just me being over-sensitive.
I hope your surgery went OK and you are recovering.
Whatever cancer throws your way, we’re right there with you.
We’re here to provide physical, financial and emotional support.
© Macmillan Cancer Support 2024 © Macmillan Cancer Support, registered charity in England and Wales (261017), Scotland (SC039907) and the Isle of Man (604). Also operating in Northern Ireland. A company limited by guarantee, registered in England and Wales company number 2400969. Isle of Man company number 4694F. Registered office: 3rd Floor, Bronze Building, The Forge, 105 Sumner Street, London, SE1 9HZ. VAT no: 668265007