Second opinion

  • 6 replies
  • 178 subscribers
  • 52 views

I am a year into my journey and it has had its ups and downs. I am now in a situation where after just a year my PSA has begun to rise. I know it is only a small reading but it has gone up from being undetectable for at 6; months to 0.04 and now the year point 0.07. As I said small readings but a definite increase. My nurse told me that the surgeon will not instigate any  investigations until  the reading is 0.1. I understand this is because any cancer which gives such low readings will ne difficult to find. My problem is that I feel the surgeon has made some errors in the treatment plan. 
it was identified on the initial biopsy that there was Perineural  invasion. My consultant said this was not an issue and would not effect the outcome. However I have read that Perineural invasion would be considered as a negative when considering nerve sparing surgery. I had nerve sparing surgery and in less than a year I am showing negative signs. 
On the biopsy from the removed prostate there was positive margins, which from my research suggests the need for closer monitoring, this has not been implemented as I went from one undetectable at 3 months straight to 6 monthly testing. The 0.04 reading was a blood test my GP asked for along with my yearly hypertension check. I have read that in some authorities positive margins are treated, why not in my case as I had 2 danger signals, perineural invasion followed by positive margins.
what should I ask the surgeon when I speak to him.

sorry if I come across as neurotic but it hasn’t been an easy ride.Al985

  • Hi AI985

    Sorry to hear PSA going up although very small amount.

    Probably too early to say what's going on , wait until the next ,PSA but possibly u need to see an oncologist rather than a surgeon because if u need further treatment salvage Radiotherapy would seem the obvious way.

    Because of very small increase time on your side, fingers crossed the next PSA will be more stable

    Best wishes 

    Steve 

  • Hello  

    Yes, it looks like you have had a very bad time with your surgery - there's no mention of PIN in your journey notes - although from my understanding with surgery they are blind until they open you up. They do have the MRI scan to go off but again - when you agree to surgery there are no guarantees.

    Your PSA is rising but it's only 0.07 - the guidelines are further treatment once your PSA is above 0.1 - and this would be Radiotherapy and possibly Hormone Therapy.

    A Second Opinion now would only suggest you need further treatment once once your PSA reaches 0.1 - if you are unhappy with your treatment to date you need to go back to the treating hospital - your first line of complaint is to the NHS Service Provider.

    I am sorry - but I am being honest with my advice, but I hope it helps.

    Best wishes - Brian.

    Community Champion badge

    Macmillan Support Line - 0808 808 00 00, 7 days a week between 8am-8pm

    Strength, Courage, Faith, Hope, Defiance, VICTORY.

    I am a Macmillan volunteer.

  • Thankyou for your supportive response. My whole journey has been a nightmare with operation cancelled as I am waiting to go into theatre and an unnecessary rigid cystoscopy under spinal anaesthesia because of a mistake made by a typist. My trust is shot.

  • Phone call today advising me of a phonecall from a nurse in 3 weeks. Apparently I am not worth a face to face appointment, and definitely with a doctor. 

    Struggling@

  • Blimey, doesn't sound good, hope things get better for you  perhaps a change of hospital at some point

    Best wishes 

    Steve 

    • I have no problem with honesty. I went for the surgical option knowing there were other options available should the cancer return. It does feel as it never went away and with perineural invasion and positive margines I expected treatment. 
    • Being a yorkshire man I am grateful for the advice not to waste money on a second opinion.
    • Thanks again for your calming and kind words
    • Al