Hello there,
I am new to this forum and am looking for some additional advice and perspectives (I plan to seek a second opinion though with a specialist).
I'm a 43 year old female.
I have more than one thyroid nodule, one of which was rated on ultrasound as TIRADS 4 with moderately suspicious features including hypoechoic, hyper/central vascularity and micro-calcifications.
An FNA biopsy came back as AUS (Bethesda 3) with less pronounced cellularity, showing thyrocytes and also Hurthle cells, single and in smaller clusters, with nuclei slightly enlarged and "moldy to each other" (nuclear molding?), but with regular contours. Vesicular chromatin. Cytoplasm moderately abundant and basophilic. The smear also contains rare macrophages, colloid and degeneratively changed cells.
I do not have Hashimotos or autoimmune thyroid (ruled out from previous blood work).
I also have a slightly high Thyroglobulin (89.26 ng/mL) and my grandmother had thyroid cancer (not sure which kind). I also have high TSH with normal T3/T4.
The largest nodule which was biopsied above is 48x19x19 mm. They are saying that given the imaging is moderately suspicious and now biopsy shows atypia, that I should have a total thyroedctomy (also for definitive diagnosis).
I want to understand if this is the best course of action?
Also, does this raise the likelihood of malignancy?
They say repeat FNA not advised and molecular testing is not available where I am (I am outside the US).
Thanks for your feedback in advance.
Best,
MJ
Hi Veex85,
Thanks for your reply. I put my surgery for the completion of thyroidectomy on hold as I needed more information and to be honest I wasn’t ready yet for another surgery physically and mentally. I did have a good talk with the surgeon and answered my questions and was quite relieved after that. I am not on any thyroid medication even after the hemithyroidectomy but surgeon said that I will have a radioactive iodine (RAI) treatment after thyroidectomy and will be on thyroxine for life. My surgery has been moved to March. The way the surgeon explained it is that the right thyroid that has been removed has cancer but tiny (5mm & 2mm) and it hasn’t spread. Cancer may not be present on the remaining thyroid but it’s better to take it out now rather than chasing it in the next couple of years, it may not happen but that is a risk to take. It’s a difficult decision to make. I hope someone in this community can reassure me. Thank you!
Hello everyone,
I have an update and would like any thoughts, also from anyone who has medical expertise? Thank you so much in advance.
My suspicious left nodule for which I was advised to have total thyroidectomy, has started to shrink while I take Thyroxin medication. I got a second opinion and the doctor who did this US, said that responsiveness to thyroid medication is much more strongly suggestive of a benign nodule, despite suspicious US features and also the atypia, which can still present in benign nodules.
He suggests I proceed with planned IVF and come back in 6 months for follow up to check the nodule again, and not to rush to surgery just now. He says if I did have total thyroid removal, it can take up to 6 months for TSH levels to stabilise which will also delay IVF and he says the slight shrinkage is a promising sign.
Any thoughts?
Thanks a lot!
Whatever cancer throws your way, we’re right there with you.
We’re here to provide physical, financial and emotional support.
© Macmillan Cancer Support 2025 © Macmillan Cancer Support, registered charity in England and Wales (261017), Scotland (SC039907) and the Isle of Man (604). Also operating in Northern Ireland. A company limited by guarantee, registered in England and Wales company number 2400969. Isle of Man company number 4694F. Registered office: 3rd Floor, Bronze Building, The Forge, 105 Sumner Street, London, SE1 9HZ. VAT no: 668265007