My husband had an xray that showed up some opacification. He was referred to the hospital on a 2ww with suspected lung cancer/mesothelioma on 27th March. He had a CT scan on 3rd April. We have now been given a face to face appointment with a consultant on 17th April. We assume this appointment is to get the results of the CT scan, but can they diagnose cancer without a biopsy? Is it good news that he hasn't been given a biopsy? I have so many questions running through my head and trying so hard to find something positive in all of this. TIA
Thank you for replying and sharing your experience. It really is a worrying time.
Hi,
This is indeed a very worrying time and not knowing for me was one of the biggest challenges.
Part of the answer is to trust the Multi-Disciplinary Team that will be reviewing all the data. It won't just be the consultant, it will also include potentially surgeons, radiologists, lung specialists, oncology, histology and more. The consultant is just the person talking to you. The MDT will discuss the medical notes and come to a joint decision.
If I'd never smoked, my Herder score would have been lower and I would be on the same surveillance as you experiencing now. I told them at the start of the process that I want all the details, so perhaps this is why I've been told all this.
The scans are more than just pictures. Things like dye uptake, something seen when dye is used, shows the activity of the cells. If uptake is low to moderate, it can indicate that it may be infection or inflammation, and it was explained to me that the normal process is to see if things change over time. If they don't, it becomes part of who we are.
I suspect the wording of the letter is about covering bases, it might be, it might not. The best way to tell is to see if it changes. It can't have enough to raise a flag for other investigations.My first letter stated this
That sounded much like I had cancer to me. A few weeks ago my letter stated
If it helps, I've been through this process with two family members who were ultimately diagnosed with cancer and the waiting game is almost the hardest part on everybody. I've had a close scare, but I am also now waiting the next CT scan to make sure nothing has changed.
David
I know the consultant has seen a load of CT scans and knows what he is looking at, but so would a radiologist. At the consultation we were told it wasn't cancer but that the nodule needed monitoring, then we we got the consultants letter and he said it was unlikely to be cancer and yesterday we got the radiologist report and it says
Sounds a little more scary now. Can the consultant tell just by looking? I wouldn't have thought so, so he is just guessing.
Thank you so much for your reply. I hope your next scan has positive results for you. Dad is having a further biopsy on his lung next week. They say they are trying to determine whether mesothelioma. I think I they are having some difficulty finding a positive result one way or another. His timeline is similar to yours so hopefully we will get a decisions of one kind or another. Your reply was really helpful. Thanks again.
Hi,
I'm sorry to hear you are stuck waiting. I'm very aware as to what that feels like. I ended up on sleeping pills due to the anxiety and at least I had more activity.
Was the previous scan done with dye? If so, they might have a low herder score and that is why it is just observation. No harm in asking them why no action and just survalance IMHO.
Take care and good luck
David
I finally got my diagnosis today, which was luckily not cancer. If they have done a PET and CT scan with dye, they may be using the Herder score to determine if it is a cancer.
As my latest biopsy has come back negative for cancer, I'm now on monitoring or surveillance and I'm due another scan in August which will be compared to the scans in February.
In terms of a timeline, this is how it went:
I hope that helps.
David
Hi. My dad is going through a similar process and we are now 3 months in and still no diagnosis. He head just been referred for another biopsy. How long did your process take. I feel we are going round in circles.
Hi pdav,
I'm sorry to hear that you and your husband are going through this.
My heart CT scan showed a lump in my lung, leading to a PET scan and a CT scan with dye. After all that, I was asked to do a biopsy. As that was inconclusive, another biopsy was requested. The point is that even though they predicted cancer after the scans, I haven't started any treatment yet and I'm told I won't until the cancer is confirmed by the biopsy. I don't know what normal practice is, but for me, after the scans came the biopsy.
I hope that helps.
Thanks
David
Hi Pdav
I’m so sorry you find yourself here in the group no one wants to be part of but you’ve come to the right place.
Everyone here is going through the same or similar as you and we’re here to support everyone that needs it while getting the support we need at the same time.
I’m sorry you have this anxious wait for your husband’s CT scan results. It’s so nerve wracking isn’t it and it seems a long wait.
I will answer your question as honestly as I can and I can say from personal experience that cancer definitely can be diagnosed from a CT scan as mine was but then I still had biopsy’s to determine the exact type of cancer, in some cases further tests to establish what gene you have but that part isn’t necessary for everyone. I had to have further tests to find a gene as my cancer was deemed inoperable and incurable at diagnoses but again everyone’s situation is different.
I had an X-ray on Christmas Eve 2024, my CT scan on 3rd January this year and was actually told by my GP on 9th January that mine was cancer as it was so clear on the CT. I was then put on the two week wait to see a thoracic consultant then the oncologist after that.
I started treatment a month ago.
I can definitely say second guessing what’s going to happen is only going to cause more stress for you both than thinking as positive as you can until you have all the facts. It’s certainly not easy I know.
If your husband does have cancer then it may be early, operable and curable, you won’t be sure of anything until you’ve seen your oncologist.
In the meantime we’re all here if you need us and we’re here to support you both.
Stay strong.
Sending positive vibes and big hugs
Jools
Whatever cancer throws your way, we’re right there with you.
We’re here to provide physical, financial and emotional support.
© Macmillan Cancer Support 2026 © Macmillan Cancer Support, registered charity in England and Wales (261017), Scotland (SC039907) and the Isle of Man (604). Also operating in Northern Ireland. A company limited by guarantee, registered in England and Wales company number 2400969. Isle of Man company number 4694F. Registered office: 3rd Floor, Bronze Building, The Forge, 105 Sumner Street, London, SE1 9HZ. VAT no: 668265007