Hi , I’m new here so I hope I’m doing it right!
I found out 2 weeks after my 50th birthday I have tonsil cancer and in lymph nodes )T2N2B) . I’m booked for surgery next week of removal of lymph nodes nodes and Transoral Robotic surgery the same day followed by Radiotherapy (6 weeks)
However I have been given a choice of the above OR chemo ( x2-3 cistplatin) and 6 weeks radiotherapy.
How on earth do people decide which is best for them?
Can I please have some insight how people came to a decision if they also had the choice?
I know neither is going to be pleasant to say the least but surely one must be better than the other? I have to decide by tomorrow for the surgery .
Are the effects of chemo in the long run worse than deciding surgery?
Is surgery with the risk? I was adamant to start that I would go down the chemo route but the last 3 days I’ve been leaning more to surgery . I know no one can help me decide . I’m so at a loss .
At first when I found out I was devastated, then for 4 days I felt confident , now I just feel utterly and completely lost.
Thankyou
I was at this exact crossroads last August. I had meetings with both my surgeons and an oncologist and both sides were getting their point across, they would likely resolve the cancer issue. It was very challenging and difficult for me and I had a very hard weekend of trying to work out what to do.
ultimately, I met again with my surgeons and they explained why surgery was what they would recommend for me over chemotherapy. I can’t tell you what to do, it’s entirely your choice but from my standpoint I decided to go down the surgery route.
My surgeon explained that I was young and likely to recovery well from surgeries and there would be a chance that this would be supplemented with radiotherapy (it was - 6 weeks). My surgeon explained that Chemotherapy was very hard on the body and her recommendation was surgery with TORS and a neck dissection first.
The surgeon did say that having gone down this route it would mean that I would have a higher chance of needing Chemotherapy in the event of a recurrence.
Im not against chemotherapy, far from it. I just opted not to go down this route to begin with. People have had combinations of therapies. In that difficult weekend that I mentioned, I sat down with my wife and wrote a list of questions and sent them to my cancer nurse. I got a call on the Monday asking me to come in for a chat and I got all of my questions answered and made my decision there and then.
I was lost at the time and I sense that’s where you are now. I would suggest contacting your nurse/consultant to discuss it further. Whatever you choose, I believe the outlook on this type of cancer to be very good.
Hello
It’s really hard being in a position of having to make choices like this. You’re hit with a diagnosis which is scary enough in itself and then, if anything like me, from a position of ignorance, asked to decide how you want it treated. I was in this position with a tumour at the base of my tongue which had spread to (only one, fortunately) the lymph node. It was the lymph node which acted as the whistleblower for the existence of the cancer..
I decided to go for surgery …for no more scientific or logical reason than a gut feeling that I just wanted rid of it. I so nearly got away with ‘just’ having the surgery. Unfortunately the margins achieved were fractionally too small, so I was hit with adjuvant radiotherapy. For me this was a far more devastating blow than the original diagnosis…..particularly as it was delivered by my surgeon’s Registrar, with no preparation, in the same breath at the end of a sentence which started ‘good news we got all the cancer’. Water under the bridge…but sometimes I wish someone would sit some of these young medics down during their training and open their eyes to the effect their choice of words …and the way they deliver them…on those receiving them….
Maybe this will sound odd….but I agonised far more, right up to the day my treatment started, over whether or not to accept the radiotherapy than whether to take the surgical route.
I don’t imagine for a moment that this helps much! It’s a difficult decision.
Good luck with your treatment whatever you decide to do.
Liz
Hi Not an easy choice. I was diagnosed in March with tonsil cancer. Was told that my tumour was small and I was a prime candidate for robotic surgery but was given the choice to have RT. I was adamant that I was not having surgery. I went away and did research. In the end I changed my mind I was told I had a 85-90% cure rate and might not need RT after.
I had neck dissection first then tors robotic surgery week later. Neck dissection was OK, was home 2 days after op and scar has healed really well. Surgery went well but I did then haemorrhage few days later ( I was warned it could happen, just bad luck). I was given emergency surgery to stop the bleed.
I'm now 3 months post op. It has been difficult at times. Had support from dietician and speech and language therapist. Had to learn to swallow and eat. was on the dreaded fortisip drinks. Also learnt how to talk again, still talking bit like I'm deaf but it is improving.
Happy to answer any questions if I can.
Good luck
Lins x
Dear Vessel6
I have only just joined this forum, having only just completed thirty days of radiotherapy myself, for what sounds a parallel and similar diagnosis:- no two are identical ( something else I have learnt in this whirlwind of new things and experiences I have had in the last six months...).
From the dates you give, I assume you have made this difficult decision, one which I have faced very recently. I had initial surgery on the tonsil and some lymph nodes in January, then I opted for more extensive surgery ( a neck dissection ton remove lymph nodes)in April, and was told that as there had been no sign of any further spread I would not need chemo - but the 30 days of radiotherapy.
I opted this way after careful discussion with my consultant - while aware that he is indeed a surgeon! However, I asked him to be absolutely frank and say what he would do if in my shoes, and in my case he said to go for the surgery, as he thought I would handle it, and the radiotherapy, well. That seems to have been right. It wasn't fun, and quite tough, and I am still impatient for the after-effects of the radiotherapy to wear off - but it is only a week and I am always impatient...
Whatever path you have chosen I hope you too have had good advice, and I wish you every success in your recovery.
With my very best wishes,
Georgeiv. ( not my real name, as advised, and I am not really royal, but I do rather admire George iv, a better king than he is often regarded...)
A week? That is super impatient…but good on you. I got worse for a good couple of weeks post treatment.
Your post made me smile. I asked my surgeon what he would have recommended had I been his mother. His first quip was that he’d have referred her to someone else…
It certainly wasn’t fun. The surgery was fine after the initial trauma healed. The radiotherapy was very much more challenging. I wish I had found this forum earlier. I would then perhaps not have gone into it as unprepared as I did. Better late than never. I’ve had some good advice here.
Good luck with the recovery. Royal banquet in a fortnight?!
Liz
Dear Liz, I too wish I had found this forum earlier. Thank you for your good wishes, and for your very parallel account, which rather matches mine. I must try harder to not be so impatient! And every good wish to you too...I am not sure whether the royal banquet will be manageable, as I am eating so slowly at the moment, but the entertainment might be worth it and take my mind off things...
George iv
Whatever cancer throws your way, we’re right there with you.
We’re here to provide physical, financial and emotional support.
© Macmillan Cancer Support 2025 © Macmillan Cancer Support, registered charity in England and Wales (261017), Scotland (SC039907) and the Isle of Man (604). Also operating in Northern Ireland. A company limited by guarantee, registered in England and Wales company number 2400969. Isle of Man company number 4694F. Registered office: 3rd Floor, Bronze Building, The Forge, 105 Sumner Street, London, SE1 9HZ. VAT no: 668265007