After a sucessful lumpectomy for estrogen,progesterone and her2 positive breast cancer, ive been offered herceptin to block the her2+. Problem is its only licensed in england to be used with chemo which i dont need. Theyve promised me only one dose of a "gental"chemo, just so i can have herceptin but why would i put any chemo into my body if its not medically required! Should i just not take the herceptin?
Hi Lillly, Happy that you had successful lumpectomy. I think it is pretty common to give chemo with her Elton unless you are over 70. Here is a link that may help to explain.
https://www.breastcancer.org/treatment/targeted-therapy/herceptin
So much information. I know herceptin is very important in Her2+ breast cancer.
Barbara
Barbara
In my post I made typo. Suppose to be herceptin not her Elton!!
Barbara
Hi my story is on profile I’m Her2 + everyone is different with regards BC and treatment plan I had EC chemo x6 even tho age 70 yr followed by Herceptin .
It has to be your decision I had Herceptin infusion every three weeks x 18 with minimal SE . You are given Heart echograms to make sure all ok .
I asked the question of why do I need it what does it achieve . The answer I was given was with Her2 there is a50% chance of recurrence within 3 yr after Herceptin it is reduced to 20% .
There a quite a few people on here with her2 + that are still around up to 15 yr after diagnosis and Herceptin myself I’m 3yr gone July .I don’t have all facts and figures so you need to make a list and ask your team so you can make right choice for you .
take care
Hi Lillly, triple positive here including HER2 positive. I had to go on Herceptin x 18 for a year every 3 weeks. However clinical trials have proven that Herceptin is only effective when combined with chemotherapy. So I also am undergoing 12 weekly sessions Taxol chemotherapy. Please note that the medics will not put you on chemotherapy unless it is of benefit to you. HER2 positive makes the cancer like aggresive type and targerted Herceptin is required to minimise the regrowth and reoccurance. But Herceptin only works well with chemotherapy.
I understand your frustations. In my case because my tumour was small only 2cm in total and successfully removed by lumpectomy and clear lymph nodes, I would not have required chemo but for HER2 gene.
Hi barbara, i am 70. This is all so confusing. Im seeing my consultant and oncologist again to clarify. Nurses advised not to take even the one chemo at this stage n i could always do it later if , i suppose , it did come back. I d decided just to take radiation and tamoxifen and had the appointment made n now im all confused again
Hi, thanks for replying. Ive read tho, that they will offer herceptin with chemo unles you are 70+ w⁷hich i am .in which case you dont have the chemo. Its so confusing but my consultant told me i didnt need it but had to have one dose just to tick the box. Oncologist said the same
I was at 70 HER2+ . I had chemo plus herceptin injections plus followed by mastectomy but no radio therapy. I can only my HER2 responded very well. Mastectomy tissue showed only a small remaining ET+ tumour for which I have exemestane. Chemo is horrible and can leave nasty after effects but it worked for me. See my profile.
Good luck x
Whatever cancer throws your way, we’re right there with you.
We’re here to provide physical, financial and emotional support.
© Macmillan Cancer Support 2025 © Macmillan Cancer Support, registered charity in England and Wales (261017), Scotland (SC039907) and the Isle of Man (604). Also operating in Northern Ireland. A company limited by guarantee, registered in England and Wales company number 2400969. Isle of Man company number 4694F. Registered office: 3rd Floor, Bronze Building, The Forge, 105 Sumner Street, London, SE1 9HZ. VAT no: 668265007