G3PT1 - BCG vs Radical Cystoscopy the choice and rationale

  • 25 replies
  • 93 subscribers
  • 1893 views

I may well be faced withe the choice soon of bladder removal vs BCG. I wonder if any others on there have faced this choice, and what what the reasons / factors for their choice / decision were?

thanks in advance,


Leo

  • With clear post op path, my consultant said 'most likely cured (95%) - only time will tell'. Now I am over 10 years post op they seem to be considering me cured. On lifetime follow up anyway to monitor my revised plumbing.

  • Interesting,my sister asked the surgeon whether I would be cured following cystectomy.He said there were no guarantees but he would do his best.Jane 

  • I don’t think BC is “curable” but only “treatable “ being a terribe pedant here I know.

  • I expected cystectomy to be worse than it was.Emotionally I did find it hard but much of that was due to recovering alone during the pandemic.I was used to looking after mum and she was stuck in the care home and my partner John had to shield.I feel mentally stronger for having gone through it and what has happened since.Jane 

  • I find that interesting too. I wonder if they would give the same recommendation to a close relative? 

    My consultant did not give any recommendation, just set out the two options (as per the NICE guidelines). When giving me the initial diagnosis & options, he did comment that BCG would be a reasonable option. He was perfectly happy with my choice to go for surgery to prioritise cure. Some people say that surgeons are keen to operate!

    I have noticed in some of the papers I have read about efficacy of BCG, it is all about numbers - as in, x certain percentage survive for y years. Or comparing it with RC, they only look at a certain number of years survival. Nothing about the human cost for those who progress & need more aggressive treatment, or indeed become incurable.

  • That's a pity if people sound dismissive of BCG. It can certainly cure in some cases  and not everyone has bad side effects. For some people, it is absolutely the right choice, for all sorts of reasons. 

    RC is certainly not to be taken lightly, and obviously has risks & side effects of its own, but for some there is no choice. Those of us who have been through it are aware that the anticipation is often worse than the actual event, which perhaps makes us gloss over the experience. 

  • Thanks Lugsy,I was a few months behind you with the cystectomy.Currently cancer free so very grateful for the surgery.Jane x

  • Hi Jane , good to see you are still on here and well done for all the help you and advice you have provided Clap Hope life's all going well for you. 

  • Hi Lugsy,Good to hear from you and that you are doing well.Best wishes Jane x

  • Cheers Lugsy, if BCG does not work out in 1st year or I get fed up with the palaver of the treatment, I will seek surgery.