Where can my daughter get supportive advice on her BRCA1 diagnosis?

FormerMember
FormerMember
  • 6 replies
  • 6 subscribers
  • 5290 views

My husband found out last year that he carries the BRCA1 gene mutation (his sister died of secondary breast cancer at 49).  Both our children got tested and both are also positive.  My 29 year-old son has had great support and advice from the NHS genetics department in the area where he lives. My daughter, however, has found the whole experience very frustrating and upsetting from the start; she was made to wait ages and go through all the bureacratic hoops to get tested, despite her risk being 50%.  She has had one appointment (early on) with a genetics counsellor and has found it hard to contact them to get another to properly talk through her options. She is now 27, in a steady relationship and, in my view, needs to make some decisions soon about having children (which will have to be IVF if she wants to avoid passing on the gene) before it becomes important to look at risk-reducing surgery if she wants it.  However, as a result of the lack of available guidance, she has just shut down the whole subject for now as too upsetting to think about. 

I have tried to look for information on the internet, but it all seems to be about having mastectomies and ovarial removal instead of a full exploration of all the possible options - such as increased screening or fallopian tube removal - and the age at which these things become critical.  I would love to be able to point her to some resources that would help her work through how to approach this massive change to how she expected her life to be. At the moment I feel helpless as her mother to be able to make this better for her. 

I would really appreciate it if anyone has found some useful resources for young women in my daughter's position, including any telephone counselling that might be open to her her, having been failed so miserably by her local NHS services.

  • Hi

    Your daughter might want to ring and speak to Macmillan (number below) and see if they can offer her some advice. 

    I've done some searches as well and, as you say, it does seem to be all about preventative mastectomies etc.

    Hopefully there may be one or two ladies in the BRCA group who have had to make similar decisions, but in the meantime, perhaps a call to the Macmillan line might point her in a new direction.

    Kindest wishes,

    Community Champion Badge

  • FormerMember
    FormerMember in reply to lesleyhelen

    Thank you Lesley.  I will suggest this to her.  I suspect that she really needs to speak to someone who has specialist understanding implications of a BRCA1 diagnosis and the options available for her particular age and circumstances.  However, just someone who is sympathetic to her needs who may be able to point her in the right direction would be a helpful start.

  • I was really sorry to learn about your daughter's difficulty in finding someone to talk to.  I have become more and more aware that it is a post code lottery.  You don't say where you live. My experience has been positive at Guy's London.  So how about asking her GP for a second opinion? I have heard good reports from Manchester as well.  I have BRCA 2 diagnosis which I realise has different issues to BRCA 1.  The other thing that I have learnt is to not accept a poor service.  My husband always comes with me and it is a united front with the medical staff.  However to be fair as I have said both the gentics team at Guy's, the breast surgeons and the plastic surgeons at St Thomas's have been great.

    All the best and keep positive

    ricki
  • I was really sorry to learn about your daughter's difficulty in finding someone to talk to.  I have become more and more aware that it is a post code lottery.  You don't say where you live. My experience has been positive at Guy's London.  So how about asking her GP for a second opinion? I have heard good reports from Manchester as well.  I have BRCA 2 diagnosis which I realise has different issues to BRCA 1.  The other thing that I have learnt is to not accept a poor service.  My husband always comes with me and it is a united front with the medical staff.  However to be fair as I have said both the gentics team at Guy's, the breast surgeons and the plastic surgeons at St Thomas's have been great.

    All the best and keep positive

    ricki
  • FormerMember
    FormerMember in reply to ricki

    Thank you Ricki. This makes me realise we need to push for a better service. My daughter lives in Bristol so would find it hard to get another opinion locally. I am wary of trying to take control from her, but I do need to help her get some better advice. As for taking someone with her - she wanted to take her boyfriend to her next appointment but hasn't been able to get a face-to-face one so far. Her GP has been of little help. I don't think those outside the genetics field really understand what a BRCA diagnosis means.

    Thanks for responding - it does help knowing that someone is listening!

  • FormerMember
    FormerMember

    Hi

    Thanks so much for posting this, I was searching for a long time to find some sort of support.

    I'm so sorry to hear about both your children being diagnosed with this. I am BRCA1 positive and also had a similar experience to your daughter (I'm 27 and Australian living in London). My genetic counsellor was emotionally unintelligent when discussing this information and couldn't reassure me that I wouldn't die from this - which isn't what you want to hear. Support goes a long way.

    I highly recommend speaking with McMillan, even if it's just an online chat as they have offered me a HUGE amount of support and information!

    Take care!

    Cara x