Hello all, new here and posting about my 58yr old dad (life-long smoker).
For about the past 18 months months (prob longer) he has had finger clubbing. My mum noticed this and told and told him to go to his GP and this can be a warning of an underlying condition. At the time he was also getting quite a bit of stomach trouble. GP was unconcerned about clubbing but sent him for a stomach camera and sigmoidoscopy of bowel. Both were clear.
In the meantime, he was told he had some hardening of the arteries and has been taking tablets to help thin the blood. On a recent visit to his GP to get blood tests (a routine check up given the meds can affect liver, etc) he saw a new GP who asked him how long his fingers have been clubbed. She listened to his chest which she said sound a bit crackly and ordered a chest x-ray which he went for on the same day. Finger clubbing can be an initial sign of LC so obviously this was very worrying.
The following day he received a "No further action" required text from the surgery in regards to his blood tests. The two days later he received the same text in regards to the x-ray. He (and mum) had gotten into a panic with all this so was very relieved at the outcome.
A full week has passed and his GP surgery rang to say he has an appointment booked for next week to see the doctor. This took him by surprise as he's received the no further action text. I suggested that given it is not an urgent appointment that she just probably wants to follow up and maybe look for other causes.
Obviously I've been Googling (I know, I know!) and have discovered that in about a quarter of people with LC an initial chest x-ray will come back negative and I wonder if the GP is looking to investigate this further. Unfortunately he is rather adamant that he does not want any further testing!! :(
Does anyone have any experience with the above? Be it digital clubbing or negative chest x-rays? I know I shouldn't be getting ahead of the situation, or worrying needlessly, but I just wondered if anyone knew how easy it might be to have LC overlooked or if the clubbing along with normal test results indicate LC could be in very early stages. If so, could anyone tell me what happens in the early stages.
Obviously, I know he has not been diagnosed and this GP seems pretty on the ball, we also don't know what the actual report on the x-ray was, but would just like to be aware of what the next stage might be just in case.
Any input is very kindly appreciated. Thank you.
Hi so sorry to hear about your Dad and the dreaded Cancer. My Mum was diagnosed in May this year, her symptoms included finger clubbing along with a very painful syndrome caused by the tumour, it was the pains in mums legs which led to the diagnosis. Luckily it seems they caught it early, she had all the diagnostic tests pet scan, bronchoscope etc and was then deemed operable, she had her lower right lobe removed at the end of July, follow ups stated no spread, she is still recovering from the trauma of it all and it has taken a huge toll on her mental health, she's went from fighting one battle to fighting another. Hope this helpsÂ
The next stage in lc diagnosis is likely to be a CT (probably thoracic and abdomen scan) or PET scan (whole body) or even an MRI scan. Any of these/all of these will confirm lc.
HOWEVER, It is NICE guidelines now to send an ex/smoker for an x ray, so don't be unduly alarmed that your dad has had one. Digital clubbing can be due to other things that cause restricted oxygenation as far as I know, so I expect the appt is to get to the root cause.
Try not to worry. Take one day at a time and stay strong x
Hi Sunshine78,
Sorry for your concerns for your dad but i'd like to suggest you are doing exactly the right thing by questioning circumstance. Unfortunately you can't get the answers you need without a firm diagnosis but you shouldn't be concerned about looking for answers. In the end information will lead you to a conclusive end and whether or not you google, ask questions of clinicians, the community here or elsewhere, it is okay to do so. It's extraordinarily difficult assessing information when emotions are high so please try get some support for yourself whilst doing so, it might make you better able to rationalise and prevent you fearing the worst, which is of course very natural. As is not knowing and being concerned by mixed messages or conflicting information.
When I was finally diagnosed with LC, one of my earlier symptoms when failures to diagnose occurred, was finger clubbing. It is closely associated with the disease but it is also associated to many other conditions and sometimes occurs without any serious underlying conditions. I think you are right to be concerned though I would try not to be alarmed at this point, which I know is much easier said than done.Â
People like myself that suffer lung cancer have very diverse symptoms, regardless of how common they may be, and there are different types of LC also. X-ray is the go to response for smokers in some way symptomatic but as you can see by other comments and probably with your own enquiries it's not always conclusive. Blood tests can also be unreliable with certain cancers so it's very difficult for family members when medical information or reports are inconclusive.
Again, I would try not to be alarmed but try to keep an open mind. I would hope you remain steadfast with your wish to get to the bottom of matters for your dad and because your dad has clubbing, after being a long term smoker, I personally would enquire with regard to a CT scan with contrast as a minimum, though obviously your dad and your GP would have to agree and refer him for that. Having said that you should understand that I have no position to argue against any medical advice your dad has received and only make that suggestion based on my limited experience and some other knowledge gained due to such. Petscan tends to be the final assessment tool with LC but I can't speak with great certainty beyond my own experience there, which was very conclusive when I was finally diagnosed, because there are so many possible variants.Â
For the moment I would take the positives from the lack of any significant findings and seek to discuss things with your parents and the GP to get to the bottom of things. It would be wrong to assume the worst from anything you've said but I think you are totally right trying to rule out the worst and seek answers for your dad's circumstance. Your dad might react in a variety of ways to investigations and findings so try to be careful not to place him between a rock and hard place, just the fear of disease can be enough to prevent people acting in ways that loved ones wish and rationalising is nearly always compromised when emotions are on the line.
All the very best to you.
Hi
Sorry you have all these worries your mind can go into overdrive when you think something may be being missed
But sometimes you have to go with instinct if you feel something may have been missed
Could you ring your GP tomorrow and ask for telephone appointment my surgery offers this facility and explain how worried you are then if it just a routine appointment you won't spend days worryingÂ
I spent 2 months going to my GP who first suspected ovarian cancer then stomach or bowel cancer as my main symptoms we're stomach related even being an ex smoker didn't raise the possibility of lung cancer so chest x ray came last on the list when everything else had been ruled outÂ
Please take the positives on the texts saying no further action as that sounds promisingÂ
Hope everything goes well for your Dad
MargaretÂ
Thank you all so much for your very kind replies and advice.
taylorduaghter ~ Thank you so much for sharing. Really sorry about your mum, but pleased to know that her LC was operable. My best wishes are sincerely with her. and yourself Interestingly, my did has had problems with his legs, although I would not describe it as being very painful. He was given a scan of his leg and this was how he was diagnosed with hardening arteries. May I ask how long your mum had the clubbing (if it's possible to know that) and how long it took for her to be diagnosed? Did she have an initial chest x-ray?
Isitokay ~ Information much appreciated. The chest x-ray in itself didn't alarm me as such, but since reading that a relatively high number of LC patients can present with normal x-rays did! A very good reason to not get caught up in googling, but yes, as you say, other respiratory conditions can cause it. However, apart form this clubbing he is not symptomatic of anything obviously lung related.
OneLungRonnie ~ Thank you so much for such a thoughtful response. It was very helpful to me. Can you tell me how long you had the finger clubbing? Would you say that was your earliest symptom? I agree to take the positives so far. My mum is quite assertive in these situations and is going with dad to his Gp appt next Monday.
Margaret ~ Thank you for your reply. It's probably not my place to ring dad's GP. He said he's just forgetting about the appt until it arrives. I'm not concerned about anything being missed as yet. This new GP was observant enough to notice the clubbing (he was there on an unrelated matter) and was also quick enough to send him for an x-ray. I am assuming this appt is a follow-up as if anything had been abnormal on the x-ray, I doubt he would be seeing the GP two weeks later. The no further action text is a bit double-edged as action IS being taken by another appt being automatically made for him, so that was a bit misleading. I think that's what has upset me. His relief at getting the text but then having the surgery ring a week later. He has also suffered with stomach issues in the recent past with nothing found to be causing them from stomach and bowel cameras.
Again thanks all. I shall keep you updated and my best wishes to you all x
Hi Sunshine78,
You're welcome.
My earliest symptom was definitely a smokers cough and it's a little difficult with the others because of a lack of awareness at the time. I was aware of the finger clubbing at some point but I'm not sure when because it happens gradually I'm led to believe. By the time I was diagnosed it was obvious to my consultant and he said my particular cancer was slow-growing and could have developed over years but I was most likely aware of the clubbing for at least 12 months along with other symptoms that I ignored or were missed.Â
My 1st x-ray showed a mass (tumour) the size of an orange in my lung so it seems like a big positive to me that your dad's hasn't shown anything. I truly hope that's the best possible reason and the clubbing is due to something else entirely and not serious.Â
Best wishes to you too and your family this xmas. x
Please do not click any links I am sure it's not safe and have flagged it to the moderators to check it.
Also this post was from 4 years ago!
Hi, I suffer from finger clubbing, I wondered for a while why my my finger nails were curling at the tips, I was being treated for Ataxia when it came to light (purely by accident) that I had lung cancer too which explained the finger clubbing, I never had a chest x-ray but have had many scans, hope your dad is ok.
Hi, my dad had finger clubbing about 10years ago and went to the drs. After loads of tests he diagnosed with farmers lung, nothing to do with cancer. He has unfortunately last month been diagnosed with stage 4 lung cancer, hes been given 6 months to live. The finger clubbing though all was farmers lung. If he had stopped smoking no further damage would have happened. Maybe its detected something like that? Hopefully, fingers crossed for you xx
Whatever cancer throws your way, we’re right there with you.
We’re here to provide physical, financial and emotional support.
© Macmillan Cancer Support 2025 © Macmillan Cancer Support, registered charity in England and Wales (261017), Scotland (SC039907) and the Isle of Man (604). Also operating in Northern Ireland. A company limited by guarantee, registered in England and Wales company number 2400969. Isle of Man company number 4694F. Registered office: 3rd Floor, Bronze Building, The Forge, 105 Sumner Street, London, SE1 9HZ. VAT no: 668265007