Ensure and the NHS

  • 16 replies
  • 86 subscribers
  • 1107 views
Are you reliant on Ensure? Is your NHS Health Service planning to stop prescribing it? And if so, how are you coping?
I had tonsil cancer SSC (treated with surgery, chemo + RT) in 2011. The cancer reoccured two years later in my pharynx and I had a significant part of my pharynx and tongue removed. I’ve not been able to eat solid food since. Initially I was feeding by PEG but through sheer determination, I managed to switch to oral feeding by blending Ensure with fruit/veg/nuts. I have successfully used this method to maintain a healthy BMI for the past 10 years. 
A bean counter at the NHS has decided that Ensure is too expensive and is being phased out. The Community Dietician has suggested a number of diet plans none of which will work for my personal circumstances. (How on earth can I swallow a cheese scone without a functioning pharynx?!) 
When they phase out Ensure, I will have little choice but to have more surgery and go back on PEG feeding, and as anyone that’s been on a PEG will tell you, that comes with its own set of problems.
Is anybody experiencing a similar issue with their Health Authority and if so, how are you overcoming the problem?
  • Hi Fulham. Just wanted to extend a welcome. I can’t quite understand what you will be prescribed via PEG. Ensure? Seems crazy 

    Can you go back to your oncology department at the hospital you were treated? After all, we are never discharged. 
    I have a friend who pulverises all her food with a vitamix. She has had a diet worked out by a private dietician and she is thriving and looking brilliant. 
    I hope you can find an answer 

    Do let us know how you get on. 

    Dani 

    Base of tongue cancer. T2N0M0 6 weeks Radiotherapy finished January 2019

    I BLOGGED MY TREATMENT 

    Macmillan Support Line -  0808 808 00 00 7 days a week between 8am-8pm

    Community Champion badge
  • Hi Beesuit
    Thank you for responding. 
    I was assigned a Community Dietician who cannot seem to grasp the complex needs of someone in my situation. She has written to my GP advising that instead of stopping the Ensures, they fade the amounts down with a view to stopping them altogether by the end of the year. It feels like a slow starvation. 
    She ‘helpfully’ included a list of foods I could include in my diet, many of which would be impossible for me to swallow. I have less than 10% function in my pharynx and am prone to aspiration.  It felt insensitive to include such a list.  Death by mash potato.  You wouldn’t write to someone with no legs and suggest they get out and walk more. 
    I did mention the Ensure matter to my Oncologist on my last visit and he was very supportive.  He wrote to my GP saying I need Ensure but he wasn’t specific about amounts.  
    The Community Dietician is suggesting I buy my own Ensure but that will cost me in excess of £4k a year and to be frank, it’s £4k I just don’t have. 
    I guess - as you wisely suggest - I will have to go back to my Oncologist and ask him to write again.  
    If that doesn’t work, I guess I’ll have to go back to PEG feeding but I’ve been on a PEG before and it’s noisy, messy, prone to infection and because I fed overnight, meant I ended up sleeping alone in the spare room so my partner could get a decent night’s sleep. 
    Not being able to eat and constantly being at risk of aspiration is bad enough but I am finding the prospect of having my food supply cut off very stressful. 
    Slightly off topic but great blog by the way!   Thanks again for taking the time to respond. :-)
  • Slightly off topic but great blog by the way!   Thanks again for taking the time to respond. :-)

    Ah…. Thankyou. 
    I am amazed a supposedly properly trained AHP can advise you in that way. 
    There are plenty of people permanently on ensures by PEG. What you are managing to do must surely be better. 
    I’m trying to think who else can fight your corner. 
    Maybe you could try contacting The Swallows charity. 

    https://theswallows.org.uk/

    They might be able to add fuel to your fire

    Dani 

    Base of tongue cancer. T2N0M0 6 weeks Radiotherapy finished January 2019

    I BLOGGED MY TREATMENT 

    Macmillan Support Line -  0808 808 00 00 7 days a week between 8am-8pm

    Community Champion badge
  • You’re so kind to take an interest and respond. And full of helpful advice too.  I hadn’t heard of Swallows. Thank you.
    I’m hoping my (helpful) Oncologist can sort the matter out before I have to start involving a charity.  I’m trying to stay calm. Getting the calories has been a huge challenge in the past and to have a feeding regime that I works for me withdrawn is unsettling to put it mildly.
    I will do all I can to battle the decision of the Community Dietician.  I am fortunate that I have reasonably good language skills and have learned to navigate the NHS, somewhat at least.  
    My wider concern is for the other people in my situation who might not have these skills.  Say, a very elderly person or someone who doesn’t speak English as a first language. So many must slip through the net.
    Your kind words mean a lot.  Thank you.
  • So many must slip through the net.

    That’s spot on. So many people here are finding that they have to be aggressively proactive to get what they need especially pre diagnosis and post treatment when wrap around care falls off a cliff. 
    Patients asking here are already proactive regarding their care but many many people just end up lost in the system. 

    Dani 

    Base of tongue cancer. T2N0M0 6 weeks Radiotherapy finished January 2019

    I BLOGGED MY TREATMENT 

    Macmillan Support Line -  0808 808 00 00 7 days a week between 8am-8pm

    Community Champion badge
  • PS

    You say you know your way round the NHS so start with your Clinical Commissioning Group responsible for the planning and commissioning of health care services for their local area.

     

    Dani 

    Base of tongue cancer. T2N0M0 6 weeks Radiotherapy finished January 2019

    I BLOGGED MY TREATMENT 

    Macmillan Support Line -  0808 808 00 00 7 days a week between 8am-8pm

    Community Champion badge
  • Hi. I had similar issues but was  2 week out of treatment. I ended up involving my oncologist and contacted the clinical commission group who both acted swiftly. It was a matter of cost the bean counters at my g p practise decided I was too expensive for their budget and prescribed me aymes which at 500 mil for 125 calories nothing like the ensures 2 kal at 125 mil for 300 calories. As you know when swallow is hard in those early days drinking 3 times as much for half the calories was too going to happen. 
    Im so sorry you’re going through this it’s so unfair seems like head and neck cancer patients are way down the list of priorities.

    As Dani has  said a lady who was in here is using a vita-mix blender with excellent results she’s peg fed so it has to be thin might be worth having as a thought. A normal blender just doesn’t get it right. 
    Sorry I had to smile at the cheese scone scenario. week 3 of treatment  my dietician said why do nt I try fish fingers chips and beans !!! As my husband said ti her A she’s not 5

    B What part don’t you gets she can’t swallow !as she’s having chemo radiotherapy for tonsil cancer ! 

    hugs Hazel 

    Hazel aka RadioactiveRaz 

    My blog is www.radioactiveraz.wordpress.com  HPV 16+ tonsil cancer Now  6 years  post treatment. 35 radiotherapy 2 chemo T2N2NM.Happily getting on with living always happy to help

    2 videos I’ve been involved with raising awareness of HNC and HPV cancers 

    https://www.instagram.com/merckhealthcare/reel/DBs8Y0niJ8N/

  • Good evening Fulham P, im PEG dependent and use Ensure as my food supplement, i can swallow thin liquids like tea, coffee etc but not Ensures as my swallow is not very good due to damage from previous operations. It does seem unfair to you as you are trying to make your diet a bit more appetizing. I wish you luck in getting this issue sorted out, all the best. 

                                                                                                      Chris x

    Its sometimes not easy but its worth it ! 

    Community Champion Badge

  • Hi Fulham

    You have done well over the past 10 years maintaining your weight under difficult circumstances. A change is so unsettling and the lack of understanding of your speech pathologist is not helping.

    I am sorry to hear of your plight. It seems the NHS are not thinking things through and not taking into account those who are dependent on Ensure to maintain their calories. Have they suggested any other supplement as an alternative that they will fund? I have had several different ones over the past couple of years and have found they all seem to have almost the same amount of calories. Because of cost (in Australia we have to buy our own supplements as they are only prescribed short term) I changed to Sustagen that I can buy over the counter at the chemists. I also bought a Vitamix blender and pulverise fruit, veg etc to a puree so get a good balanced diet that way. Sounds as though you are doing something similar.

    I am fortunate as I have just been able to upgrade my diet after a jaw reconstruction op but am still reliant on Fortisip to help maintain the calories. (had a change to my finances so am now able to afford the Fortisip)

    Can you look outside the box and do a problem solve so that if the worst comes to the worst you can come up with an alternative to help you maintain your weight ? You have already been very innovative and I'm sure you will be able to find something that works for you. It's just so disappointing though that others in the medical system are not that helpful. I have found that I have had to work out a lot around diet myself to find what works best for me.

    I do hope you get a quick resolution.

    Lyn

    Sophie66

  • Morning Fulham

    I am RIG dependand, unfortately i'm not familiar with Ensure, I have feed from a company called Fresenius Kabi, who supply everything i need, once a month, it maybe worth asking your dietitan about them.

    You said that you found PEG feeding noisy, the machines may have changed since you had one and maybe alot quieter now, i also feed at night and don't find it a problem with the noise.

    I can understand your reluctance going back to tube feeding, i've had so many problems with mine, but 90% of my problems are down to the fault of the surgeon that fitted it. They are a pain having them and a work up, but it's what is keeping me alive, so i put up with it.

    I am lucky enough to be able to eat very small amounts of curtain soft foods cut into little pieces, so i know how much you would miss being able to blend your veg etc. The feed from Kabi doesn't smell nice and i wouldn't like to blend it with anything, maybe there is something else you could use instead. 

    Good luck, i hope all works out for you.

    Cat x