What would you do: go private or NHS?

  • 19 replies
  • 38 subscribers
  • 383 views

Hello. This is all very new so please forgive the lack of information.
My partner has recently been diagnosed with prostate cancer (looking like advanced). No numbers or levels yet, but CT showed it in lymph nodes and PSA 60  

lots more tests including biopsy and bone scan yet to happen  

We've just discovered we have full private healthcare, but we also understand this is where the NHS can also be at its best, when needing urgent care. 

Do we have to have one or the other? From your experience, what would you do? private or NHS?

  • Good Morning  

    A warm welcome to the Macmillan Online Community, although I am so sorry to find you here. I am Brian, one of the Community Champions here and indeed I am just starting my 4th year on my own Prostate Cancer journey. (you can read my journey by clicking on my user name or avatar).

    The Community is divided into various cancer specific chat rooms, or groups and I would advise you to join the Prostate group where you will be amongst Community members on the same or similar journey as your partner - here's the link -

    Prostate cancer forum 

    When you click on the link and the page opens up, click on "join" on the black banner at the bottom of the page. You can then either copy and paste or repost your original post in the "New Here - Say Hello" section. You will get a warm welcome from the members of "our" group - we are a great bunch.

    If I can do anything else for you please do let me know, otherwise I look forward to "meeting" you again in "our own" part of the Community.

    Best wishes - Brian

    Community Champion badge

    Macmillan Support Line - 0808 808 00 00, 7 days a week between 8am-8pm

    Strength, Courage, Faith, Hope, Defiance, VICTORY.

    I am a Macmillan volunteer.

  • Hi, I also have private health cover and had expected to go that route.  That said, to be honest there wasn't really time to "move" to private.  If you see my other post you will see the whole diagnosis journey so far, including almost 2 weeks as an inpatient in the local hospital hasn't really left much time to get in touch with the private folks, organise a private consultation etc. etc.  I have to say that so far as I can tell the level of NHS care throughout has been very high, making me think I wouldn't have been better off with private.  Private remains an option for treatment but for now given my experience so far I plan to remain with the NHS.  Which is not at all what I had expected.

  • My experience of another cancer is that private care is very useful if referral and diagnosis is delayed but once you are in the system NHS is best. 
    You can combine too

    I know people who had chemo privately at home and the rest of their care NHS based

    Dani 

    Base of tongue cancer. T2N0M0 6 weeks Radiotherapy finished January 2019

    I BLOGGED MY TREATMENT 

    Macmillan Support Line -  0808 808 00 00 7 days a week between 8am-8pm

    Community Champion badge
  • Thank you so much for this

  • Thanks for this Chris. Have you claimed for your stays in hospital from the private healthcare? 

  • Thanks so much Dani, that’s really helpful Heart

  • Hi, it's all very new so I am about to.  With Aviva there is a cash allowance of £100 per night up to 30 nights, which I am about to claim against.  Will let you know how it goes.

  • Good luck Chris, and make sure you tell them ALL of the tests and stays you have had in hosp so far. 

  • Good Morning  

    I have noticed you haven't joined us yet on the Prostate Group - link here:

     Prostate cancer forum 

    You will find plenty of other Community members there with extensive experience of Private/NHS treatment.  there's lots of great advice too to help Mr G on his journey. I look forward to "meeting" you there.

    Best wishes - Brian.

    Community Champion badge

    Macmillan Support Line - 0808 808 00 00, 7 days a week between 8am-8pm

    Strength, Courage, Faith, Hope, Defiance, VICTORY.

    I am a Macmillan volunteer.

  • Hi Beesuit,

    Hope you don't mind asking a question please, I've just been diagnosed with prostate cancer and trying to find out exactly what you just mentioned. I do agree the NHS are amazing and the way they have treated me over the last few months is fantastic, however I was trying to find out about private surgery and NHS care following. When you get told you have cancer you google for days and days, and a treatment I have considered is not available in my local hospital area, however available in London, Yorkshire, Portsmouth and a few other NHS hospitals. When I asked the urologist regarding a private treatment, and he said I would fall out of the NHS system for this diagnosis, where I had hoped the after care and monitoring (PSA blood tests etc) would be done at my local hospital, without paying for the next ten years or so. I don't have private medical insurance, I have just retired and have a pension, which may cover the cost, I haven't approached privately yet though since seeing the urologist a few weeks ago,

    Thanks for any help or advice,

    High regards, Edz