Hello!
Back in June a CT for a colon infection noted an incidental finding of a mass on my left kidney which was removed in August and confirmed at my post surgery review to be a ccrcc which was contained with no spread but also grade 4. How do people work that out in their head that they have good news but also that it could return? The word agressive in this case is so unsettling - I can't get my head around the conflict of "all removed, we just need to monitor you" and "it was agressive, so we need to monitor you" if that makes sense?
Time.
I was diagnosed in Nov 2021 and had treatment including a trial until June 2024. I recognised that I could do nothing about the success of my treatment, or whether it would re-grow. My tumour remains at 23mm and "managed".
Over time I came to terms with the uncertainty. I set myself a target of 5 years (due Nov 2026) then age 60 (2029) then 70 (2039) as a stretch Target. This was really for my "entertainment ". It amused me.
Now I am in a completely different place. Of course, this is assisted by the time lapse and my good response to treatment. But there is no quick win to be had in this space. These are big and frequently complex issues we are dealing with.
I would also add that kidney cancer has always lagged behind other cancers in terms of adjuvant treatment. Where as it appears other cancers have A or B or C, many options, to mitigate a return of the bu55er, kidney cancer *just* scanned every 3 months or / and pembrolizumab immunotherapy for 3-6 months. But this immuno approach is very new. It's just become available in the last 3 years.
I don't think the pembro approach is universal for all ccRCC types, but it would or should or could be for yours.
Many thanks for your comments - I really appreciate seeing it from your perspective of a few years down the line. My tumour was 68mm and they removed it and my whole kidney so no treatment for now, just monitoring. This is all very new to me and I think it's just overwhelming and a big learning curve still.
Hi VeeDub, I think maybe the reason they are just monitoring you and have not offered you immunotherapy could be because your kidney tumour was “contained with no spread” . So by removing the tumour and your whole kidney, your current medical status is presumably “NED” (no evidence of disease) - do check that with your doctors. If so that is good news. I was also “NED” following surgery about 6 months ago, BUT they also found a second tumour, a small metastasis, on my adrenal gland and that, I believe, is what made the crucial difference to the follow up - I’m on immunotherapy (Pembro) for a year as well as the monitoring scans. Of course I’m not a doctor and I may be wrong, but this is how I understand the rationale - in my case - behind just monitoring, or monitoring plus treatment.
Exactly the same here. Grade 4 cancer after total nephrectomy.
I'm also on monitoring with no other treatments. However I've had 3 scans since the op last December and nothing has returned though I haven't heard about the last one 4 weeks ago. I hope no news is good news!
I went through a phase when I thought I was just waiting to die but that has now passed.
It's difficult, we can't control our emotions but time for me has been a great healer.
Hang in there.
After a pulmonary embolism, a large, aggressive tumor was found on my left kidney. The cancer had grown into my venae cavae but had not spread, even into the adjacent adrenal gland. A radical nephrectomy and thrombectomy removed all cancer. A CT scan later verified no cancer as of that point. I was surprised to be diagnosed as stage 4, since the tumor was removed in one piece and no spreading in what I considered the traditional sense had occurred. I became pretty depressed and upset about it. After speaking to my surgeon, he termed it as stage 4 “minus”. Which actually helped me psychologically (probably his intent). I am on Keytruda and probably will be for some time but I never considered myself as much at risk as Stage 4s where the cancer spread and was being kept in check medically. My medical team said the Keytruda was in part to keep sleeper cells in check(sounds like terrorism) and I reconciled myself to this description and treatment. I think very much in the present and enjoy my life in between scans as I know how bad it could have been. CT scans every 3 months and immunotherapy for up to two years. Not sure in your case why no immunotherapy but what I assume for you will be imaging every three months will help find anything immediately should it arise. Hope this helped a little!
Thank you - it's so interesting to understand other people's experiences too. The no immunotherapy in my case is because there was not thought to be any spread. I think my mind is just blown by the whole 'grade 4' thing to be honest. I know regular scans will monitor any potential return but it's just blown my mind and I have to just come to terms with this new reality. You have all said that time will help with this and I appreciate each and every response. I am just slow at processing I think!
Whatever cancer throws your way, we’re right there with you.
We’re here to provide physical, financial and emotional support.
© Macmillan Cancer Support 2026 © Macmillan Cancer Support, registered charity in England and Wales (261017), Scotland (SC039907) and the Isle of Man (604). Also operating in Northern Ireland. A company limited by guarantee, registered in England and Wales company number 2400969. Isle of Man company number 4694F. Registered office: 3rd Floor, Bronze Building, The Forge, 105 Sumner Street, London, SE1 9HZ. VAT no: 668265007