Metastatic Papillary RCC

  • 3 replies
  • 46 subscribers
  • 611 views

Hello friends

I’ve been part of this forum for about 3 months now and in that time I’ve noted many of  my fellow sufferers have metastatic  RCC and have also undergone immunotherapy. 

What I’ve never considered until now is how many of you have Clear Cell RCC as opposed to  Papillary RCC and whether this may have  a bearing on  how it’s treated. I have Papillary RCC.  

I was first diagnosed in 2008 and had a right radical nephrectomy  I didn’t need any further treatment at the time as the cancer hadn’t spread at that time.  

Its wasn’t until 2014 that the disease had developed with metastatic lesions in both of my lungs and thoracic lymph nodes. 

Apart from a 7month period from May 2017 till January 2018 when I had fortnightly IV infusions of Nivolumab immunotherapy I have been on targeted inhibitors of various sorts (details of which are on my profile). I found that I suffered little if no side affects with Nivolumab where as I’ve always had some severe side affects with targeted daily aural inhibitors At best very minimal reduction to lesions has been noted but mainly the treatment has served to slow growth down however both  lungs are now dramatically very diseased.

What I have noted reading postings on this forum how many cite quite dramatic reduction of metastasises on combination immunotherapy which is something I’ve never been offered so I was wondering if having Papillary rather than Clear cell has any bearing on that or whether it’s just down to Consultant choice..

If any of you specifically with Papillary RCC could let me know what immunotherapy you have received and how successful it has been I would love to hear from you. 

Thanks for listening

Rojan

  • Very.  Interesting.  Post.  

    My understanding is the treatment you are offered is limited by drug licence.  There's more trials for the more commonly occurring cancers therefore more variable treatment options available.   

    Compare kidney cancer with breast cancer for example.  BC is one of the more common cancers, there are loads more treatment options, and adjuvant options common place as well.  As a kidney cancer community adjuvant treatment is still in trial stage for us.   

    My belief is it's all down to the numbers with your cancer type.  Larger population for a trial, better statistical results (you can't prove anything with small sample size), errrr . . . . . . .  and the dynamics of capitalism unfortunately.  

    Stats from the Cancer Research UK web:

    • clear cell - around 80 out of 100 renal cell cancers (75%)
    • papillary - around 15 in 100 renal cell cancers (15%)
    • chromophobe renal cell cancer - around 5 in 100 renal cell cancers (5%)
  • Quite and it’s a principle I’ve encountered in targeted inhibitors. That’s why I was particularly wondering if there are any more among us than me that have papillary RCC but have been offered combined immunotherapy. 
    As I’ve already posted previously, the years of severe side affects suffered with targeted inhibitors having battered my body to the extent that I no longer have any quality of life has led me to the drastic decision to stop treatment. However knowing how well I tolerated Nivolumab I maybe happy to try combined immunotherapy if it was available to me. 
    I have an appointment with my Consultant on Friday and would have liked to have some anecdotal data to hit him with in fact anyone has any. 
    Thanks for your feedback and as ever your interest.  I’m still hoping for good news from the trial that are currently part of. I hope it’s going well. 

  • Hello Rojan,

    My husband was diagnosed last July with Pappillary RCC, which unfortunately had spread to the lungs. lymph nodes and adrenal glands. The initial treatment he received was Nivolumab and Ipilimumab together for four doses given at 3 weekly intervals. They then stopped the Ipilimumab and he continued to receive the Nivolumab at three weekly intervals. This was stopped after a ct scan showed that although it was working on most of the growths, the ones on his adrenal glands had doubled in size.

    He was then started on 60mg of Cabozantinib, this he had for about 6 weeks before the side effects became to much for him, so he has been on 40mg for the last 3 months but last week we have had to stop it for a break, he is constantly suffering from the severe side effects and is not well at all. He has had every single side effect going on all three treatments, he was managing them quite well while on just Nivolumab before it was stopped.

    He is due another scan tomorrow, with the results in next week, fingers crossed for better news.

    We were told before he started any treatment that the Ipilimumab could only be given  for 4 doses on the first treatment cycle, but I am sorry I can't remember why this was.

    Hope you find something that works better for you and fingers crossed no side effects.