Surgery or Watch and Wait

  • 1 reply
  • 39 subscribers
  • 144 views

Hello,

I am writing on behalf of my wife who was diagnosed with rectal cancer last October. After a 5 week course of chemo radiation has now been told she has had a complete response. This is great news but the surgeon still advises a resection with a permanent colostomy. He wasn’t very encouraging about a watch and wait approach so we wanted to find out more before making a decision.

He said surgery was the ‘gold standard’ and safest option to prevent the cancer returning and said that if it did return then they could only offer palliative care which of course was very frightening so we were thinking that the surgery was the only sensible option.

However, having looked at some information on here we are less sure. Even with surgery there still some chance of cancer return in other places but he didn’t mention this. With close monitoring surely any spread would be monitored more closely than the monitoring after surgery? I asked about TNT but he said she didn’t need it. He also asked if a PET scan might be helpful but he said it didn’t show up small bits of cancer but I thought that was the whole point. We have gone from being totally confident in our surgeon to very confused and worried.

She has now been offered a sigmoidoscopy on Monday and in the letter from the surgeon that came this morning, he said if she wanted to watch and wait she could have a PET scan. We thought we could try watch and wait for a while and it it became too stressful then opt for surgery but don’t know if this would be difficult because of scar tissue etc. The list of surgery risks that accompanied the letter was very frightening and I know that these have to be mentioned but there were no percentages to help with knowing how likely the various scenarios are. (Death for example!)

I appreciate you cannot make any recommendations etc but if we could find out where to get more information on the statistics of outcomes after surgery versus a watch and wait approach we would be very grateful.

Thank you.

  • Hi Mals,

    Thanks for getting in touch and welcome to our online community.

    My name is Lindsey and I’m one of the Cancer Information Nurses on the Macmillan Support Line.

    I’m pleased to hear that your wife has had a complete response to her treatment for her rectal cancer.

    I can appreciate that being faced with a decision to have surgery or to watch and wait is difficult for you and your wife.

    You did not mention if your wife has had a chance to talk this through with her Oncologist. The Oncologist will understand about her current options and can talk through the benefits of each one. You could also discuss what options your wife would have if she elected to watch and wait and the cancer came back. Would there be an option for surgery if the cancer came back locally? Would other treatments or clinical trails be available?

    Our booklet Making Treatment Decisions has been written to help you pull together the information you need to make decisions.

    Your wife’s specialist nurse will help you both to talk through the options you face and your concerns over having surgery.

    You would both be welcome to contact our support line to talk things through on 0808 808 0000 every day 8am until 8pm.

    With Kind Regards,

    Lindsey

    Ref: Lrob/IY